Welcome to Perfect Pony Patisserie
Custom Decorated Sugar Cookies & Gourmet Cookie Cart in Sebastopol, CA
Perfect Pony Patisserie is a Sebastopol, California bakery specializing
in custom decorated sugar cookies for every occasion. Whether you need
a dozen beautifully decorated cookies for a baby shower, birthday, bridal
shower, or retirement party — or you want to grab freshly baked gourmet
cookies from our weekend cookie cart — we've got you covered.
Serving all of Sonoma County with local pickup and nationwide shipping.
Satisfy Your Sweet Tooth!
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Where is Perfect Pony Patisserie located?
A: We're located at 5775 Blank Rd, Sebastopol, CA 95472 in Sonoma County. Local pickup is available throughout the Sebastopol area. We also ship nationwide — just note that orders with delicate thin designs may not be accepted for shipping due to breakage risk.
Q: How do I order custom decorated sugar cookies?
A: Fill out our custom cookie inquiry form on the Order Online page. Tell us your event date, flavor preference, theme, and how many dozens you need. We respond to all inquiries within 48 hours. Once your order is accepted, a 50% deposit is due to secure your date and the remaining 50% is due at delivery or shipping.
Q: What flavors do custom sugar cookies come in?
A: Custom sugar cookies are available in three flavors — Original (contains almond extract), Original with no almond extract, and Chocolate. Please let us know about any allergies when you place your inquiry.
Q: What is the Cookie Cart and how does it work?
A: The cookie cart is our self-serve weekend pickup option featuring freshly baked gourmet cookies. Pre-orders are due by 10am every Thursday for that weekend's cart. You can order up to 12 of any one flavor with a minimum of 2 per flavor. Flavors include Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Oatmeal, Caramel Snickerdoodle, Double Chocolate, Super Chip, Brown Butter Chocolate Chip, and Cookies & Crème — all $2.50 each. Sonoma County sales tax of 10.7% applies.
Q: Do you offer vegan or gluten-free cookies?
A: Yes! We offer vegan and gluten-friendly options for both gourmet and custom sugar cookies. Vegan and GF gourmet cookies are $30 per dozen. Vegan and GF custom sugar cookies are $55 per dozen. Please mention your dietary needs in your order inquiry.
Q: How far in advance should I order custom cookies?
A: We recommend placing your custom cookie inquiry at least 2 weeks before your event date. For larger orders or complex designs, 3–4 weeks is even better. The sooner you reach out, the better we can guarantee your date.
Q: What occasions do you make custom cookies for?
A: We create custom decorated sugar cookies for baby showers, birthdays, bridal showers, weddings, retirement parties, holidays, corporate events, and any occasion worth celebrating. If you can dream it, we can probably cookie it.